PFAS40/ 100Poor
Overall24/ 100Bad
Citizen CZ Smart Men's Smartwatch with Leather Strap

Citizen · Water-Resistant Smart Rings & Bands

Citizen CZ Smart Men's Smartwatch with Leather Strap

Poor

Smartwatch waterproofing likely contains PFAS with limited transparency.

Verdict · SkipSmartwatch with acceptable material core; PFAS waterproofing concern and leather durability require informed maintenance.

Citizen provides no PFAS disclosure for this smartwatch. Waterproof electronics typically use fluorinated coatings.

The better-graded swap

Original HONOR Insix Smart Health Ring X1A-08/10/12 Works with HONOR Magic V3

Honor

Original HONOR Insix Smart Health Ring X1A-08/10/12 Works with HONOR Magic V3

85/100 safety

85Excellent

Same rubric that flunked this product. The swap earned Excellent.

Still want this one anyway? Check the price on Amazon. We’d swap it.

Material

Stainless steel case, leather strap, unspecified waterproof coating

Brand disclosure

Brand is silent on PFAS

Lab data

No public lab test

What’s concerning

♾️

No PFAS disclosure

No public statement from the brand about PFAS in this product.

85/ 100
♾️

Category baseline

The starting point for this type of product, before anything specific to this product is counted.

90/ 100
♾️

Waterproof / stain-resistant treatment

Water-repellent coating treatments have historically used PFAS.

65/ 100
💨

Formaldehyde / VOCs

Leather straps are typically chrome or vegetable-tanned, but finishing processes may use formaldehyde-releasing resins. Direct skin contact is limited to the wrist, reducing exposure, but individuals with contact sensitivity may develop mild irritation. No recalls recorded for this product.

Source, ATSDR
70/ 100

Coating degradation and particulate release

Waterproof coatings on smartwatches can flake or degrade under repeated stress (moisture cycling, flexing at case seams). The actual composition is unknown; if Teflon-type coating-based, flaking particles are inert but visible deterioration signals breach of waterproofing. Risk increases after 3-5 years of regular wear.

70/ 100
⚠️

Stainless steel nickel content

Stainless steel (typically 300-series) contains 8-12% nickel, which can leach in small amounts on prolonged skin contact, especially in acidic conditions (sweat). Individuals with nickel contact dermatitis may experience localized rash under the watch band or case. Most people tolerate this exposure without issue.

70/ 100
⚠️

Unspecified waterproof sealant or adhesive

Smartwatch cases use gaskets, adhesives, or press-fit seals whose composition Citizen does not disclose. These may release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) or residual solvents, especially if the watch is new. Ventilation and initial 24-48 hour wear at arm's length can minimize exposure.

70/ 100

The full breakdown

What it's made of and why it matters

This watch pairs a stainless steel case (inert, low-leach) with a leather strap and an unspecified waterproof coating on the case and seals. Stainless steel itself poses no established leaching risk under normal wear. The leather strap introduces potential formaldehyde residue from tanning and finishing processes, though exposure is minimal in typical use. The waterproof coating is the primary concern, Citizen does not publicly disclose whether it uses Teflon-type coating (Teflon-family coating) or other fluorinated compounds, which are the most common waterproofing agents in this product class.

The brand's record and disclosure

Citizen has not published detailed material safety or PFAS transparency data for smartwatches. The company maintains no publicly searchable restricted substance list specific to wearables. Citizen has faced no major recalls for smartwatch chemical hazards on record. Their silence on waterproof coating composition is typical of the watch industry but limits consumer ability to assess PFAS exposure; a handful of competitors (notably some sustainable watch brands) now disclose fluorine-free coatings, making Citizen's position appear less precautionary by comparison.

How it compares in its category

Smartwatches sit between apparel and electronics; this model's stainless steel case and leather strap are conventional materials. Most mainstream smartwatches (Apple Watch, Garmin, Fossil Group) rely on similar waterproof coatings without disclosure, making Citizen typical rather than exceptional. Brands with explicit fluorine-free or PFAS-free claims remain a small premium segment. For a mass-market smart timepiece, this product's material profile is standard and not an outlier.

If you buy it

Rotate the leather strap every 6-12 months or replace if it shows cracking, fading, or odor (signs of tanning residue degradation and wear). Clean under the case and around seals monthly with a dry cloth to prevent moisture and dust accumulation that stresses waterproof coatings. Avoid prolonged immersion in saltwater or chlorine, which can corrode stainless steel and compromise coatings. Do not expose the strap to prolonged heat (over 140F/60C) or direct sunlight for extended periods, as this accelerates leather degradation and potential chemical release.

What we don’t know

Basis
Model estimate, 45% confidence, not a lab result
Lab test
None on record for this exact product
Brand statement
Citizen has made none

Formulations change between production runs, so check the current label. How we grade.

Better-graded alternatives in Water-Resistant Smart Rings & Bands

Amazfit Helio Smart Ring Health Tracker

Amazfit

Helio Smart Ring Health Tracker

Titanium alloy case, polymer band

PFAS Grade85Excellent
Overall Grade77Excellent
⚠️

Polymer band composition and residual monomers

Limited concern

70
⚠️

Bacterial growth in sealed band-case junction

Limited concern

70

No coating described, and no PFAS statement from the brand.

Brand says nothing about PFAS

Oura Ring 4 Size Smart Ring

Oura

Ring 4 Size Smart Ring

Titanium, stainless steel core

PFAS Grade85Excellent
Overall Grade59Good

Seal degradation and water ingress

Limited concern

70
⛏️

Nickel leaching from stainless steel

Limited concern

70
⚠️

Bacterial colonization in band crevices

Moderate concern

45
⚠️

Skin allergen from metal sensitivity

Limited concern

70

No coating described, and no PFAS statement from the brand.

Brand says nothing about PFAS

Oura Ring 4 Ceramic Smart Ring with 8-Day Battery

Oura

Ring 4 Ceramic Smart Ring with 8-Day Battery

Titanium and ceramic composite ring

PFAS Grade85Excellent
Overall Grade77Excellent

Ceramic coating degradation

Limited concern

70
⚠️

Nickel in titanium alloy

Limited concern

70

Ceramic and titanium pose lower PFAS risk; brand is silent.

Brand says nothing about PFAS

More water-resistant smart rings & bands grades

How we score, every product runs through the same public 0-100 rubric based on materials, coatings, brand disclosure, lab findings, and recalls. See the full methodology → Spotted a mistake? Report an error.