Maybelline Line Express Sharpenable Wood Pencil Eyeliner
Skip until Maybelline reveals waterproofing method.
Maybelline doesn't disclose how this eyeliner stays waterproof. Waterproof cosmetics commonly rely on fluorinated compounds, leaving PFAS risk unconfirmed.
The safe swap
Ere Perez
ERE PEREZ JOJOBA EYE PENCIL Natural Black
75/100 safety
Same rubric that flunked this product. The swap earned Excellent.
Still want this one anyway? Check the price on Amazon. We’d swap it.
Material
wood pencil with presumed waterproof pigment/wax formulation
Brand disclosure
Brand is silent on PFAS
Lab data
No public lab test
What’s concerning
Waterproof / stain-resistant treatment
Water-repellent treatments have historically contained PFAS chemicals.
Category baseline
PFAS exposure happens more often with clothing products.
No PFAS disclosure
The company has not publicly discussed PFAS in this product.
Heavy metals
Iron oxides, mica, and synthetic organic dyes used in eyeshadow and eyeliner pencils may contain trace lead or cadmium depending on pigment sourcing and manufacturing controls. Maybelline does not publish heavy-metal testing data for individual shades, so risk cannot be quantified; long-term periocular exposure is low but not zero.
Source: FDA ↗Fragrance allergens and sensitizers
If this pencil includes fragrance or essential oils (common in wood-pencil formulations for sensory appeal), undisclosed fragrance mixtures can trigger contact dermatitis or eye irritation in sensitive individuals. Maybelline lists fragrance on some eyeliner products but often does not specify individual components.
Bacterial contamination from wood casing and sharpening
Wood is porous and can harbor bacteria if the pencil is exposed to moisture or shared; sharpening creates a fresh exposed surface that may not be sterile. Improper sharpening or storage increases risk of introducing pathogens to the periocular area, especially if the skin barrier is compromised.
PFAS
Waterproof eyeliner pencils commonly rely on PFAS-containing silicone or Teflon-family coating coatings to resist water; Maybelline has not publicly stated which waterproofing method is used here. This absence of disclosure is the primary safety concern and the reason for the 'Skip' recommendation unless the brand clarifies.
Source: ATSDR ↗Coating degradation and microparticle shedding
As the pencil is sharpened repeatedly, wax and pigment particles are shed into the sharpener and can be transferred to hands or eyes. Over time, the wood may splinter or the outer finish may degrade, potentially introducing splinters or degraded coating material to the sensitive eye area.
The full breakdown
What it's made of and why it matters
This product is a sharpened wood-cased pencil eyeliner, meaning the pigment and binder are pressed into a waxy or resinous core, likely containing iron oxides, mica, and synthetic colorants held together with wax or polymeric binders. The wood casing itself introduces minor contact with tree resins and any finishes applied to the pencil exterior. Waterproofing formulations in pencil eyeliners traditionally rely on waxes, silicones, or film-forming polymers, but Maybelline has not publicly disclosed whether PFAS compounds are used to achieve water resistance in this specific product.
The brand's record and disclosure
Maybelline (owned by L'Oreal) does not maintain a published PFAS-free commitment or transparency report on per-product waterproofing agents. The brand has faced no major recalls specific to this eyeliner product, but cosmetics manufacturers in this category rarely voluntarily disclose heavy-metal limits or pigment sourcing. Maybelline offers no third-party certification (e.g., EWG verification, Leaping Bunny) for this line, making independent safety verification difficult.
How it compares in its category
Pencil eyeliners are generally considered lower-risk than liquid formulas because they contain less solvent and fewer preservatives, but waterproof pencils sit in a gray zone where PFAS is common across budget and mid-tier brands. Premium or natural alternatives (e.g., Beautycounter, RMS Beauty) typically disclose waterproofing methods; drugstore brands like Maybelline and Wet n Wild rarely do. This product's cost and convenience appeal but lag significantly in transparency versus comparable options.
If you buy it
Patch-test on the inner arm or eyelid margin 24 hours before full use to rule out pigment sensitivity or allergic reaction to binders. Sharpen with a clean, dedicated pencil sharpener to avoid bacterial colonization; do not share with others. Replace every 6-12 months or if the tip becomes frayed or the formulation visibly separates. Remove with gentle makeup remover rather than rubbing, which can damage the eye barrier and increase penetration of any leached pigments.
What we don’t know
- Basis
- Model estimate, 35% confidence, not a lab result
- Lab test
- None on record for this exact product
- Brand statement
- Maybelline has made none
Formulations change between production runs, so check the current label. How we grade.
Safer alternatives in Eyeliner
MAC
Chromaline Gel - Hi-Def Cyan
gel pigment formulation (primary ingredients not publicly disclosed for proprietary reasons)
Heavy metals
Limited concern
Formaldehyde / VOCs
Limited concern
1,4-dioxane (contaminant in polyethylene glycol or emulsifiers)
Limited concern
Eye irritation from film formers or fragrance compounds
Moderate concern
Lower concern, but brand doesn't disclose full formulation details.
⚠Risky category by default
Ere Perez
Jojoba Eye Pencil Gem (lilac haze)
Jojoba oil, waxes, pigments (typical pencil formulation)
Fragrance allergens
Limited concern
Microorganism growth in oil matrix
Limited concern
Eye irritation or sensitization from wax/oil breakdown
Limited concern
Lower concern. Natural formula shows no PFAS risk signals.
⚠Risky category by default
Ere Perez
JOJOBA EYE PENCIL Natural Black
Jojoba oil, waxes, pigments (natural eye pencil formulation)
Fragrance allergens or essential oil irritants
Limited concern
Microbial or oxidative degradation of oil base
Limited concern
Lower concern. Natural formulation unlikely to contain deliberate PFAS.
⚠Risky category by default
More eyeliner grades
How we score: every product runs through the same public 0–100 rubric based on materials, coatings, brand disclosure, lab findings, and recalls. See the full methodology → Spotted a mistake? Report an error.